When Fatherhood is Challenged: Disproving Paternity

The concept of fatherhood is a fundamental part of family law and is based on the biological relationship between a father and his child. 

However, there are instances when this relationship is called into question, and the paternity of a child is challenged. 

The legal consequences of disproving paternity or overcoming presumed paternity can be significant. This article aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the legal procedures for disproving paternity and overcoming presumed paternity.

What Is Paternity 

Paternity is the legal identification of a man as the biological father of a child. It establishes a legal relationship between a father and child and may involve rights and responsibilities such as child support, visitation, and custody.

What is Presumed Paternity, and What Are The Legal Implications of Being a Presumed Father? 

Presumed paternity is a legal concept that refers to the assumption that a man is a child’s biological father, even without conclusive genetic testing. 

Below are some common examples of when a man is presumed to be the father of a child: 

  1. He is married to the child’s mother at the time of the child’s birth or within 300 days after the marriage is terminated by death, annulment, divorce, or dissolution.
  2. He and the child’s mother are married, and the child is born after they file a separation agreement in court.
  3. He signed an Acknowledgment of Paternity Affidavit, which was filed with the central paternity registry.
  4. He voluntarily signed a birth certificate acknowledging the paternity of a child.
  5. A man who holds out the child as his own, publicly representing the child as his biological offspring, may be presumed to be the child’s father.
  6. In some cases, a man who has supported a child financially for a significant period of time may be presumed to be the child’s father, even if he is not biologically related.

The legal implications of being a presumed father are significant, as it establishes a man’s legal rights and responsibilities concerning the child. 

For example, a presumed father will have a legal duty to provide financial support for the child and the right to seek custody or visitation. 

Related Articles

How Common is it to Attempt to Disprove Paternity? 

Disproving paternity and overcoming presumed paternity is more common than many people realize. 

According to some estimates, up to 10% of all paternity claims are disputed, and up to 30% of children born to unmarried parents have uncertain paternity. 

These figures highlight the prevalence of paternity disputes and the need to understand the legal consequences of challenging paternity better.

What is the Legal Standard to Overcome Presumed Paternity? 

In most cases, the legal standard to overcome presumed paternity is “clear and convincing” evidence that proves the presumed father is not the child’s biological father. 

Clear and convincing evidence” is a legal standard of proof that requires evidence to be highly and substantially more probable to be true than not. 

It falls between the lower standard of “preponderance of the evidence” and “beyond a reasonable doubt.” 

It is often used in civil cases, including paternity cases, where the consequences of the decision are significant but not as severe as in criminal cases.

How To Disprove Paternity – Understanding DNA Testing and Its Role in Disproving Paternity

DNA testing is the most reliable method for establishing paternity and disproving paternity. The process involves comparing the genetic markers of a child and a potential father to determine the likelihood of a biological relationship.

Several types of DNA tests are available, including genetic marker testing, which compares specific DNA sequences between the child and potential father, and whole genome sequencing, which examines the entire DNA sequence of both individuals. 

Legal Strategies for Challenging Presumed Paternity

The steps to legally disprove presumed paternity may vary depending on the jurisdiction but typically include the following:

1. Obtain a DNA Test

A DNA test can provide clear and convincing evidence to challenge presumed fatherhood. This usually involves collecting DNA samples from the child, the presumed father, and the alleged biological father.

2. File a Paternity Action

The person seeking to disprove presumed paternity must file a legal action in court. This action could be initiated by either the mother, the presumed father, or the alleged biological father.

3. Serve Legal Documents

Once the paternity action is filed, the parties involved must be served with legal documents, called a summons, notifying them of the lawsuit. 

4. Attend a Hearing

The court will schedule a hearing to determine the issue of paternity. During the hearing, the parties can present evidence and testimony to support their positions. The DNA test results will be the critical piece of evidence.

5. Obtain a Court Order

If the court finds that the evidence presented is clear and convincing enough to disprove the presumed paternity, a court order will be issued to reflect the new determination of paternity. 

It is important to note that the legal process to disprove presumed paternity can be complex and time-consuming. It is recommended to seek the advice of a qualified attorney in such cases.

Financial Implications of Disproving Paternity

Disproving paternity can have significant financial implications for all parties involved. 

For the presumed father, it may mean being relieved of financial obligations such as child support and other financial responsibilities. 

For the biological father, it may mean assuming financial responsibilities for the child, such as child support.

A Real-Life Example of Disproving Paternity

Here’s a well-known story about Carnell Alexander from Michigan, USA. In 1991, he received a letter from the state claiming that he owed thousands of dollars in child support for a child he had allegedly fathered eight years earlier. 

Carnell was shocked, as he had never heard of the child before. He went to court to challenge the claim but was told that he had missed the original hearing and the default judgment had already been entered against him. 

He was ordered to pay child support and arrears, and his driver’s license was suspended when he couldn’t afford to make the payments.

Carnell was adamant that he was not the child’s father and requested a DNA test, but he was told it was too late. He spent years trying to fight the ruling and clear his name, but the courts denied him the chance to prove his innocence.

It wasn’t until 2013, over 20 years later, that Carnell finally got a DNA test that proved he was not the child’s biological father. With the help of the University of Michigan Law School’s Innocence Clinic, he got the judgment overturned, and his child support payments stopped.

The case received widespread media attention and highlighted the flaws in the child support system, particularly in cases where paternity is assumed based on outdated or incomplete information. It also showed how difficult it can be for someone to challenge a paternity ruling, even with modern DNA testing.


Q. Can I disprove paternity if I have already signed a birth certificate?

Yes, it is possible to challenge paternity even if you have signed a birth certificate. However, you must file a petition to disestablish paternity to remove your legal obligation to support the child.

Q. Can I disprove paternity if I have been paying child support?

Yes, it is possible to disprove paternity even if you have been paying child support. However, you must file a petition to disestablish paternity to remove your legal obligation to support the child.

Q. How long do I have to challenge paternity?

The time limit for challenging paternity varies from state to state. In most cases, you have limited time to challenge paternity after the child is born. It is essential to consult with a qualified attorney to determine the time limit in your state.


Challenging paternity can be a complex and difficult process. However, with the help of a qualified attorney, it is possible to disprove paternity and protect your rights as a father. 

By following the steps outlined in this guide and seeking the help of a qualified attorney, you can achieve the best possible outcome for you and your family. 

What To Read Next


Tim McDuffey is a practicing attorney in the State of Missouri. Tim is a licensed member of the Missouri Bar and Missouri Bar Association.

Recent Posts