Child Custody Rights for Unmarried Mothers: Understanding Common Custody Mistakes

When it comes to child custody, understanding your rights as an unmarried mother is crucial. Unmarried mothers have certain legal rights that protect their interests and those of their children. 

These rights may vary depending on your state, but there are several fundamental principles that apply in most jurisdictions:

Legal Rights of Unmarried Mothers

1. Presumption of Maternal Custody

In most states, an unmarried mother is the legal custodian of her children by default. This means she has the legal right to make decisions regarding her children’s upbringing, education, healthcare, and other matters without any additional legal steps. 

2. The Right to Physical Custody

The mother generally has the right to physical custody of the child, which means the child lives with her.

3. The Right To Parent The Child 

The mother is responsible for the day-to-day care and upbringing of the child, including providing food, clothing, shelter, and emotional support.

4. The Right to Make Decisions for the Children

The mother has the authority to make important decisions regarding the child’s life, such as healthcare choices, education, religious upbringing, and extracurricular activities.

5. The Right To Obtain Child Support

An unmarried mother typically has the right to seek child support from the child’s father. Child support is a legal obligation that ensures both parents contribute financially to the upbringing and well-being of their children, regardless of their marital status.

Common Mistakes an Unmarried Mother Should Avoid

While every situation is unique, there are several common mistakes that unmarried mothers should avoid when dealing with custody and child support matters. 

By being aware of these pitfalls, they can better protect their rights and their children’s best interests:

Mistake 1: Not Legally Establishing Paternity

Establishing paternity, or legally identifying the father of a child, can be important for several reasons. 

It can play a crucial role in legal matters related to child support, custody, inheritance, and access to medical records, among other things.

Example One: The Relationship with the Father Deteriorated and Father Refused to Pay Child Support

I had a client once who was an unmarried mother. She and the father did not intend to get married. She decided not to legally establish paternity after the birth, thinking it was unnecessary because they were on good terms and he was involved in their child’s life.

Unfortunately, as life moved on, their relationship began to deteriorate. They started disagreeing about how to raise their child, and eventually, the father stopped visiting. 

On a limited income, the mother started struggling to make ends meet. She needed financial support to care for their child’s necessities – food, clothing, medical expenses, and education.

Without established paternity, she found it extremely difficult to request child support legally. She came to me for help. I explained to her that the court needed evidence that the man she claimed was the father indeed was the biological father, and she couldn’t provide this without a legal document or DNA test. 

She was stuck in a difficult situation, bearing all financial responsibilities alone. We had to file a formal petition to establish paternity and child support, which took almost a year to complete. 

Example Two: Medical Complication of the Child

I also once had a client whose child fell seriously ill. The doctors urgently needed a complete family medical history to help diagnose and treat the condition. Without established paternity, accessing the father’s medical history became problematic, which delayed the child’s treatment.

Example Three: Lost Inheritance

Finally, without legal paternity, a child could miss out on inheritance rights or benefits like social security or veterans benefits. 

My clients discovered that not establishing paternity disadvantaged them and their children in several ways. So, unmarried women need to consider establishing paternity to safeguard their children’s rights and secure a support system.

Mistake 2: Not Establishing Legal Custody, Visitation, and Child Support

Establishing legal custody, visitation rights, and child support is essential in safeguarding the best interests of the child, as well as the rights of both parents. 

It ensures a stable and consistent environment for the child and defines the responsibilities and rights of both parents.

I had an unmarried client who had a child with a man. Early on, they lived together and shared the responsibilities of raising their child, so the mother didn’t think it was necessary to establish legal custody, visitation rights, or child support.

Several years passed, and the relationship between the mother and father became strained. They decided to live separately, and problems started to arise. 

The father stopped returning the child at the designated time and began to limit the mother’s time with the child. The informal financial contributions he had been making became irregular and then stopped altogether.

Without legal custody established, the mother found herself powerless. When she tried to assert her rights, she realized she had no concrete way of ensuring that she could spend adequate time with her child. 

And, without a visitation agreement, the father could deny her access whenever he wished. The inconsistency and unpredictability of this situation was distressing for both the mother and the child.

Regarding financial support, the mother was now solely responsible for the child’s expenses. She was left struggling to cover all the costs of raising a child alone. Since there was no court-ordered child support, the father was under no legal obligation to contribute, leaving the mother in a precarious financial situation.

Had she established legal custody, visitation rights, and child support, the mother would have been able to ensure consistent access to her child, and there would be a set amount the father was legally obliged to contribute towards raising their child. 

This would have created a more stable environment for the child and ensured that the mother had the financial help necessary to provide for their child’s needs.

Therefore, even if parents are on good terms and share responsibilities, I recommend to my clients to legally define these aspects to protect the rights of both the parents and the child and prevent potential problems that could arise.

Mistake 3: Thinking You Can Prevent Visitation With The Father Because You Don’t Want Him In Your Child’s Life

When it comes to parenting, the decisions made by either parent can have long-term consequences and emotional impacts on the child.

Let’s take a case I once was involved in for a father. The mother and father were in a relationship but weren’t married when the mother got pregnant. 

Their relationship had always been turbulent, so the mother decided not to include the father’s name on the birth certificate when the baby was born. In her view, this was a way to protect the child from potential harm due to their unstable relationship.

The father sincerely wanted to be part of his child’s life. In the months following the birth, he began making significant life changes. He worked on improving his lifestyle, securing steady employment, and focusing on personal development and growth.

Aware that his name was not on the birth certificate, the father realized he had no legal rights to his child and could not ensure regular visitation. 

He wanted to be a part of his child’s life, not just emotionally and physically, but legally as well. He knew he needed to prove his commitment and show he could provide the child with a stable and supportive environment.

He decided to petition the court to establish paternity and secure visitation rights. This involved filing a petition and, in most cases, submitting to a DNA test to confirm biological paternity.

The legal process was challenging and emotionally taxing. The father faced resistance from the mother and had to convince the court of his sincere intentions and capability to be a good parent. 

The court examined his living conditions, employment status, and overall lifestyle to determine if granting visitation rights was in the child’s best interest.

Eventually, the court granted the father visitation rights after he proved his paternity. The DNA results confirmed he was the biological father, and his actions demonstrated his commitment to providing a stable and nurturing environment for his child.

In this scenario, the father’s persistence in establishing his legal rights ensured that he could be a part of his child’s life, despite the initial decisions made by the mother. 

It underscores the importance of legal frameworks in protecting the rights and best interests of the child and those of both parents.

How To Establish Parental Rights Though Paternity

When it comes to determining parental rights, establishing paternity is crucial. Paternity testing can be requested by the mother or the putative father to determine the biological relationship between the child and the alleged father. 

If the father’s identity is confirmed through paternity testing, his rights and responsibilities can be established.

Voluntary Acknowledgment of Paternity

When the child’s biological father willingly acknowledges paternity, an unmarried mother’s rights to child custody become more secure. 

Voluntary acknowledgment of paternity is typically done by signing a legal document, such as a paternity affidavit or acknowledgment of paternity form, in the presence of witnesses or notarization.


Q. Can a father establish paternity and secure visitation rights if his name is not on the birth certificate?”

Yes, a father can petition the court to establish paternity and secure visitation rights, even if his name is not on the birth certificate. This process often involves submitting to a DNA test to confirm biological paternity. After proving paternity, the father can request visitation rights or even custody. Here is a detailed article discussing this topic:

Q. What are the potential impacts on the child if the father’s name is not on the birth certificate?”

If the father’s name is not on the birth certificate, it might potentially complicate inheritance rights, access to medical records, and social benefits. It may also affect the child emotionally, as they might have questions about their identity and feelings of abandonment.

Q. What can a mother do if she didn’t initially establish legal custody or child support and now requires it?”

If a mother didn’t initially establish legal custody or child support but now needs it, she can petition the court. She will need to file for custody and child support. 

This will likely involve a process where the court will examine factors such as income, living conditions, and the child’s overall well-being to determine an appropriate child support amount and custody arrangement. 

If the father’s paternity hasn’t been legally established, that may be a necessary first step. The process might be complex and potentially stressful, so legal advice is recommended.

Q. Can unmarried fathers seek custody rights? 

Yes, unmarried fathers can seek custody rights by establishing paternity and demonstrating a commitment to their child’s welfare. They have the right to participate in custody proceedings and request visitation or joint custody.

What To Read Next


Tim McDuffey is a practicing attorney in the State of Missouri. Tim is a licensed member of the Missouri Bar and Missouri Bar Association.

Recent Posts